Spiders🕷. Please don't put a pic on my answer. LOL
What's creepy? (Besides Hippy's ex, of course. I mean, I have nightmares about that face! ..shivers)
Donald Trump's hair.
I've watch a lot of horror movies and the creepiest thing I have seen is "The Grudge" ambling down the stairs . . . The croaking sounds sends shivers down my spine.