I don't believe in the supernatural because, by definition, universal laws are universal (all-encompassing). That means they take care of what we don't observe.
I believe in the paranormal because there is always a realm beyond science. The immeasurable parts of life are the most powerful. That being said, I don't believe in dumb paranormal things.
People who are too "rational" miss out on the fact that most of our universe is unobservable by our senses (we take in very few vibrations and are conscious of even fewer). People who are too irrational believe bad stories.
...we can't really escape our narrative needs though :(
SO YES AND NO AND I DON'T KNOW!